Retry in head-to-head?
Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2006 4:09 am
The rule should be clarified as to what happens to the OTHER racer on a retry when doing a head-to-head race:
A) Other racer MUST do a retry. (Retry the entire run with both racers. Both racer's 1st run thrown away.)
B) Other racer may ELECT to take a retry run. (The faster of the 2 runs is used for this racer).
C) Other racer may ELECT to take a retry run. If he does, that 2nd run is the one that counts and the 1st run is thrown away.
I propose that option C is the best. Let me use an extreme example:
By some stroke of luck, I qualify in position #32. I am pitted against Chris Barker who qualified #1. We take our 1st run head-to-head. Chris easily is beating me by 6 cones or more. I get interfered with and abandon the race. Chris finishes normally. I want a re-run. Should Chris be forced to do a re-run? I don't think so. He has so many other races to run, no need to get all tired out.
A) Other racer MUST do a retry. (Retry the entire run with both racers. Both racer's 1st run thrown away.)
B) Other racer may ELECT to take a retry run. (The faster of the 2 runs is used for this racer).
C) Other racer may ELECT to take a retry run. If he does, that 2nd run is the one that counts and the 1st run is thrown away.
I propose that option C is the best. Let me use an extreme example:
By some stroke of luck, I qualify in position #32. I am pitted against Chris Barker who qualified #1. We take our 1st run head-to-head. Chris easily is beating me by 6 cones or more. I get interfered with and abandon the race. Chris finishes normally. I want a re-run. Should Chris be forced to do a re-run? I don't think so. He has so many other races to run, no need to get all tired out.